Right: Highlands Farms, a retirement community in Black
Mountain, offers residents a full range of amenities -- and a gorgeous view.
Carefree Isn't Free
You can retire comfortably, with great
healthcare, just be aware why they're
called the Golden Years
By Heidi Russell Rafferty
If your mental image of retirement evokes the Old
Folks Home, where life is slow and peaceful, then you may be shocked to learn
what the market has prepared for you and the rest of the Baby Boomers.
Retirement communities are the rage these days, places that couple many of the
same amenities available at the best resorts with top-notch medical care and
personal services. But there’s a catch. Living large at these retirement
communities isn’t cheap, with typical prices running $2,000 a month or more.
And there’s another catch: Other than your Social Security check, forget about
much if any help from Uncle Sam.
Retirement communities are popular because they offer the ability to easily
transition from independent living to assisted care to skilled nursing care over
a period of years, so you only need to move once. The package usually includes a
wide range of services. Highland Farms, a retirement community in Black
Mountain, offers three meals a day, weekly linen service, an activities program,
all utilities, housekeeping, personal assistance and an emergency call system.
“The Baby Boomers are going to
retire earlier and will want to be able to maintain an independent lifestyle,
but they also want the maintenance lifestyle,” says Pat Winebrenner, the
marketing director at Highland Farms. Most of Highland Farms’ 390 residents
live in free-standing cluster homes, paying from $1,600 to $3,700 per month,
depending on payment plan.
Being able to afford such a carefree retirement lifestyle, with secure
healthcare, is a concern shared by a growing number of people. By 2010, the
oldest of the Baby Boom generation will turn 65, according to the state Division
of Aging. They will be the first wave of more than 2 million North Carolinians
born between 1946 and 1964. They represent nearly one-third of the state
population and double the number of older adults from the previous generation.
The Division of Aging reports that it’s likely that boomers will want to
continue living in their own homes as long as possible (like their parents), but
they will want more choices, and more customized services. The same will be true
if they need residential care. Many of the high-end assisted living programs are
being developed now to appeal to boomers — first for their parents, then as
the consumers themselves, the division says.
Retirement planners say an estimated 40 percent of the population will need some
form of long-term care at least once in their lifetimes. “Long-term care” is
defined as the different kinds of help available to people with chronic
illnesses, disabilities or other conditions. More than 5 million people
nationwide receive some type of help with their daily activities — either at
home or in assisted living facilities, board and care homes, adult foster care
homes, nursing homes and adult day care centers.
But the average yearly cost of long-term care can be expensive. In North
Carolina, nursing home costs average $130-$135 per day, or $48,000 per year,
according to the state Department of Insurance. To receive the same type of care
at home, a person would pay $15,000 to $25,000 a year.
One major problem is that the aging population misunderstands financial help
available from the government, and therefore, they plan inadequately, says Kay
Tomlinson, assistant deputy commissioner of the Seniors’ Health Insurance
Information Program, or SHIIP. Most people incorrectly think they can tap into
Medicaid or Medicare, Tomlinson says. Part of Medicare pays for skilled nursing,
but it only covers up to 100 days, and only 20 days receive full coverage, she
“Only 2 percent of nursing home care is covered by Medicare, because it’s
skilled nursing care. If people are getting better and no longer need the care,
Medicare won’t pay for intermediate or custodial care,” Tomlinson says.
The Medicaid benefit is for people who are impoverished. “The problem with
that is that you have to have very limited income and resources,” Tomlinson
says. “You can only have assets of $2,000 if you’re an individual and $3,000
for a couple. There is an income limit as well. Some people think they can give
away their assets to qualify, but Medicaid looks back at three years to see if
you’ve done that. Medicaid is a resource of last resort for people. It is not
good to count on it to pay for long-term care expenses.”
Renee Brumagin, marketing director for Baptist Retirement Homes of N.C., says
the misconception over Medicare and Medicaid leads families to make poor
choices. “They are always in a crisis state when some event happens, and they
have to do something quick,” she says. “The problem is that a lot of
facilities won’t even take Medicaid anymore. Then you end up in a not-good
situation with poor care.”
Baptist Retirement Homes, based in Winston-Salem, has 700 beds statewide —
including Brookridge — and will be opening its fifth facility in Concord in
October. Brumagin says the community “provides care to the poorest person who
was a farmer and on Social Security, all the way up to the founders of Lowe’s,
Tabasco and Texas Pete. We run the whole gamut.”
She notes it’s important for families to spend time investigating all of the
potential communities where their parents might locate before they get too
“Most of the good communities do not allow an overnight decision. There is a
lot of paperwork to fill out before you make a decision. A lot of education
still has to be done with the public. You can’t wait until you need care.”
Brumagin says that once you are admitted to Baptist, you are never asked to
leave, regardless of whether you run out of money. “But you truly have to run
out. You can’t give it away and put it into an estate. A lot of people are
living longer these days. If you outlive your resources, we pick up the
difference. We raise a lot of money for benevolent care.”
Protect Your Assets
Even the wealthiest of us should carefully consider long-term care insurance,
according to retirement planning experts who say it’s a financial tool
overlooked by many Americans.
The cost varies with your age and the options you select. The older you are, the
higher your monthly premiums will be. Although such the policy will not
appreciate or provide a return on your investment, it is a protection for your
investment portfolio. R. Michael Shively, vice president of the Estate
Preservation Department for Salomon Smith Barney Inc. in Charlotte and a
retirement planning specialist for 33 years, advises clients to consider the
product by the time they’re in their 50s. Salomon Smith Barney recently sent
out a mailing to 64,000 clients in 23 states urging the use of long-term care
An investment side fund would not necessarily beat the value of long-term care
insurance in the long run, Shively says. “What are you going to earn (on your
investments), and what will you have at the time when you need it? What you’ll
find is, you never know when you’ll need that coverage,” Shively says.
But he and others caution that you should evaluate your current assets, income
and personal preferences before deciding whether to buy long-term insurance. You
may pay premiums for 15 to 20 years before you need the services. Shively,
Jackson and Tomlinson agree that insurance is for people who either want to
protect their assets, provide their assets for heirs or want to maintain choice
and be independent from the government or family for care.
“We don’t recommend it, and most financial planners don’t recommend it,
for people who have less than $80,000 to $100,000 in assets — not counting the
house,” Tomlinson says. “The premiums will rise. Certainly, people on fixed
incomes should not be thinking about it. There are some planners who say that
millionaires don’t need it, either, because they can self-pay, but that’s a
The state Department of Insurance recommends that you should not pay more than 7
to 10 percent of your income for health premiums, including long-term care
insurance. “For people in that range who have assets they want to protect,
long-term health insurance is a good product,” Tomlinson says.
Weigh the Options
You should buy long-term care insurance before you become disabled or seriously
ill. Many people won’t begin using their benefits when they are in their 80s,
but an unexpected accident, disability or disease such as Alzheimer’s may
cause you to need them sooner.
Buying long-term care insurance requires three main decisions. The first is your
daily benefit, or the amount of money you will receive on a daily basis for your
care. You can usually select from $50 to $250 per day. The second is the benefit
period, or the length of time you will receive payments. You can usually select
a specific number of years, or you can choose a lifetime plan. The average stay
in a nursing home is 2 ½ to 3 years. The third consideration is the elimination
period, or the number of days that you will be responsible for paying for your
care before the insurance begins to pay. This is like most insurance deductibles
except it is stated in a number of days instead of dollars.
Bob Jackson, the director of the AARP office for North Carolina, says that in
the past 10 to 15 years newer insurance products have emerged that provide
additional protections that the old style did not. For example, some offer an
optional inflation protection, which builds in an automatic increase each year
in per-day value of the product. “That means if you buy a $100 per day plan
today, without inflation protection, 10 to 15 years from now when you need it,
the cost for care will have gone up dramatically,” he says.
Another feature is the non-forfeiture provision, which means that, after you
have paid on the plan for a period of time and you decide you don’t want the
product anymore, you can cancel the plan. You can either get cash back or some
kind of paid up coverage, Jackson says.
The definition of covered facilities has also improved, Jackson says. In the
past, the insurance only paid if you were in a certain type of nursing facility.
Now the policies have improved to pay for care in your home or for a family
member to care for you in their home.
“Some also provide for home modifications, such as ramps and rails,”
Tomlinson adds. “It depends on what you’re looking for. It’s just like
shopping for cars. Do you want the
basic model or the Cadillac with more bells and whistles? It depends on your
Tomlinson says it’s important that consumers study each contract and listen
carefully to their insurance agent to determine what their policy will and will
not cover. Couples should also consider “pooled benefits.” That means they
can both use the benefits, even if one gets sick before the other.
The Department of Insurance reviews all long-term care policies, and companies
must be licensed or authorized to do business in North Carolina. Jackson says
consumers should ask the Insurance Department for a carrier’s history of rate
“What we’ve seen over the last 10 years is that products were sold, and the
companies said they wouldn’t raise their rates. But there was a small print
clause that said they wouldn’t raise an individual’s rates unless they
raised everyone else’s. We’ve seen a lot of companies raising rates 15 to 30
percent,” Jackson says.
Other recommendations: Make sure your agent obtains in writing the company’s
current A.M. Best Rating. Tomlinson says it should be at least an A. You also
should make sure the agent is licensed in North Carolina. In addition, nearly
all states, including North Carolina, require that insurance companies give you
a 30-day free look period, which begins after you receive the signed policy.
During this period, you can return a policy and receive a full refund.
Also look at whether your policy is tax qualified, which refers to certain tax
advantages for buying long-term care insurance. Most are, Tomlinson says. The
federal government does not tax benefits paid under tax-qualified policies, and
a portion of the premiums you pay may be tax deductible.
To receive benefits under a tax-qualified policy, a medical professional must
certify that you will need help with two out of six activities of daily living
for at least 90 days. The amount of your premiums that you can deduct depends on
your age at the end of each taxable year.
Long-term care insurance isn’t for everyone, but other options exist for
people who can’t afford the premiums and who also may not qualify for
Medicaid. R. Michael Shively, vice president of the Estate Preservation
Department for Salomon Smith Barney Inc. in Charlotte, says companies have found
other ways to package long-term care provisions with other products.
“Some combine a single premium life insurance product with a long-term care
feature,” Shively says. “So you have someone who doesn’t want to pay the
(long-term care insurance) premiums, but perhaps they have older life insurance
policies. They can do an exchange to a new product that will also provide the
long-term care products.”
People can also consider investing in annuities, he says. “Some carriers
provide annuities with a benefit of long-term care after the annuity has been in
force for a number of years.” Shively says a lot of annuity carriers will take
a withdrawal from the annuity to provide for the long-term care insurance
People in the middle-income range should look at affordable long-term care
insurance plans, even if they only cover nursing home costs and don’t carry
the bells and whistles of more expensive policies, Shively says.
Some retirement communities also offer payment plans to help people plan better
for their future, says Karen Daniel, director of admissions and public relations
at Carol Woods, a community in Chapel Hill with 425 residents.
Carol Woods, for example, charges an entry fee based on the size of the
independent living arrangement. As part of that fee, the resident pre-pays the
cost of future healthcare that he or she will need. This “modified contract”
spreads the cost of healthcare over time, Daniel says.
“This lessens the likelihood of full medical costs at the end of a life,”
Daniel says, adding that the question one should ask is when to pay for health
care, not whether it will be needed. “You’ll pay for the healthcare either
up front, when you’re using it, or you can spread the cost along, but you will
pay for it, one way or another,” she says.
Return to magazine